Unfortunately, none of these edge controllers have worked for me. I found when I used these products they all had the same effect. I like my hair to lay down straight and flat. But these edge controllers only made the frizz worse. Even when I brushed the baby hairs forward instead of back they still just curled up instead of laying like I want them to. So I will not be using any of these products again. I can’t say I don’t recommend any of these products; I really believe it just depends on the hair type.